You are looking at a DocketDB detail page about an active case pending in the Texas Supreme Court. To learn more, click here.
IRVING W. MARKS
v.
ST. LUKE'S EPISCOPAL HOSPITAL
Decided for 7 days
Opinions Issued

Medina Hecht Wainwright Johnson Willett
Opinion of the Court
Justice Medina delivered an opinion of the Court, in which Justice Hecht joined, and in which Justice Wainwright, Justice Johnson, and Justice Willett joined as to Parts I & IV. (PDF)
Wainwright
Concurring
Justice Wainwright delivered a concurring opinion. (PDF)
Johnson Hecht Wainwright Willett
Concurring
Justice Johnson delivered a concurring opinion, in which Justice Willett joined, and in which Justice Hecht joined as to Parts II and III-A, and in which Justice Wainwright joined as to Parts I, II, and III-A. (PDF)
Jefferson Green Guzman Lehrmann
Concurring and Dissenting
Chief Justice Jefferson delivered an opinion concurring in part and dissenting in part, in which Justice Green, Justice Guzman, and Justice Lehrmann joined. (PDF)
Guzman
Concurring and Dissenting
Justice Guzman delivered an opinion concurring in part and dissenting in part. (PDF)
Recent Events
    7 days ago: Previous opinion withdrawn
    7 days ago: previous judgment withdrawn
    7 days ago: Opinion issued
    7 days ago: Concurring opinion issued.
    7 days ago: Concurring opinion issued.
    7 days ago: Concurring and dissenting opinion delivered
    7 days ago: Concurring and dissenting opinion delivered
    7 days ago: Court approved judgment sent to attys of record
Docket Sheet
2007-09-27 PETITION FOR REVIEW FILED – Petitioner
2007-09-27 Appendix to Brief filed – Petitioner
2007-10-02 Response to Petition for Review waived (see remark – Respondent
2007-10-09 Case forwarded to Court –  
2007-11-06 response to requested; due ____; see remarks – Indicates filing re Petition for Review View Sheet
2007-12-04 response to petition for review filed – Respondent
2007-12-20 reply filed – Petitioner
2008-01-28 briefing on the merits requested – Indicates filing re Petition for Review
2008-01-28 Record Requested in Petition for Review –  
2008-02-04 Case Record Filed – Clerk of the Court of Appeals
2008-02-13 Electronic Copy of Brief Posted to Web – Petitioner
2008-02-13 Electronic Copy of Brief Posted to Web – Respondent
2008-02-13 Electronic Copy of Brief Posted to Web – Petitioner
2008-02-28 Brief filed. – Petitioner
2008-03-11 Motion for extension of time to file brief. – Respondent
2008-03-11 Electronic Copy of Brief Posted to Web – Petitioner
2008-03-11 Phone call from Clerk's Office. – Respondent
2008-03-13 motion for extension of time (remarks) – Respondent View Sheet
2008-04-01 Brief filed. – Respondent
2008-04-16 Reply brief. – Petitioner
2008-04-24 Electronic Copy of Brief Posted to Web – Petitioner
2008-04-24 Electronic Copy of Brief Posted to Web – Respondent
2008-05-16 Petition for Review under Rule 53 Disposed of – OA date & time not set. View Sheet
2008-05-16 pet/rev granted –  
2008-08-13 Case set for oral argument – Indicates filing re Petition for Review
2008-08-13 Phone call from Clerk's Office. –  
2008-08-21 Phone call from Clerk's Office. – Petitioner
2008-08-22 Oral Argument Submission Form from Attorney received – Respondent
2008-08-22 Oral Argument Submission Form from Attorney received – Petitioner
2008-09-04 call from atty in case – Respondent
2008-09-11 Exhibits in case/cause filed – Respondent
2008-09-11 Oral argument - –  
2008-09-24 Post submission brief – Petitioner
2008-09-24 Response to brief – Respondent
2008-09-24 Electronic Copy of Brief Posted to Web – Petitioner
2008-09-25 Electronic Copy of Brief Posted to Web – Respondent
2009-08-28 Opinion issued – To identify a cause in
2009-08-28 Concurring opinion issued. –  
2009-08-28 Dissenting opinion issued. –  
2009-08-28 Dissenting opinion issued. –  
2009-08-28 Court approved judgment sent to attys of record –  
2009-08-28 Dissenting opinion issued. –  
2009-09-29 m/e/t to file motion for rehearing – Respondent
2009-10-01 M/E/T to file Motion for Rehearing disposed – Respondent View Sheet
2009-10-05 Designation of Lead Counsel – Respondent
2009-10-14 m/e/t to file motion for rehearing – Respondent
2009-10-16 M/E/T to file Motion for Rehearing disposed – Respondent View Sheet
2009-11-13 Motion for Rehearing - Filed – Respondent's Motion for Rehearing of Cause filed
2009-11-13 Case forwarded to Court –  
2009-11-20 File instrument. – Petitioner
2009-12-14 Amicus Curiae Brief received – Received (instead of filed)
2010-01-08 Amicus Curiae Brief received – Received (instead of filed)
2010-01-08 Amicus Curiae Brief received – Received (instead of filed)
2010-01-11 Amicus Curiae Brief received – Received (instead of filed)
2010-01-14 Supreme Court of Texas Requested Response; mailbox rule does not apply – Indicates motion for rehearing. See Event
2010-01-25 M/E/T to file response – Petitioner
2010-01-26 Motion for Extension of Time disposed. – ** See Remarks View Sheet
2010-02-19 Response to Motion for Rehearing – Petitioner
2010-04-09 Motion for Rehearing - Disposed – To identify a cause in View Sheet
2010-04-09 Motion for Rehearing Granted –  
2010-08-27 Previous opinion withdrawn –  
2010-08-27 previous judgment withdrawn –  
2010-08-27 Opinion issued – To identify a cause in
2010-08-27 Concurring opinion issued. –  
2010-08-27 Concurring opinion issued. –  
2010-08-27 Concurring and dissenting opinion delivered –  
2010-08-27 Concurring and dissenting opinion delivered –  
2010-08-27 Court approved judgment sent to attys of record –  
Courts Below
Court of Appeals:
Houston (1st COA)
No. 01-04-00228-CV docket
by Honorable Samuel M. Nuchia

Trial Court:
Harris County
Honorable Levi James Benton